Aaron Kreuter
Colby’s Paradox
It was the night the coral were supposed to release their yearly gamete bundles into their glass bathtubs. A controlled and monitored version of the frenzy that would soon overtake their cousins out in the reef. The same every November. People started arriving at the windowless laboratory around seven thirty. At eight o’clock, the fake sun started to fake set. The project leaders, scientists, undergrads, and various assorted switched on their headlamps, held buttons till they glowed red, whispered reverentially over the gurgle of the tanks, pointing and speculating. The red lights milled around, shone into the water, waited for the coral to set, for each of the thousands of tiny polyps to produce a hard little nub. A biological precursor to release.
By eleven, an eternity of waiting, it seemed unlikely there would be any action tonight. A hundred red lights bobbed toward the exit.
“Not to worry, it’ll definitely be tomorrow,” Thomas said to Anna-Maria.
“I just have to get something from my car, meet you at the dorms,” Clare said to Colby.
“Good night, sweet things,” Olatokunbo said to the tanks.
The door shut on the coral, leaving them to their simulated night.
Colby sat on the rocking chair behind the research centre’s dorm rooms, watching the rolling ocean. She had had one too many pulls from Helmut’s absurdly massive bottle of vodka, was trying to clear her head and take a break from the raucous reunion vibes inside. She could see Olatokunbo with some of the undergrads down in the surf. They were swaying and shouting their promises into the salty air, the sky above them smeared with clouds and stars, sex, drugs, rock and roll.
It was a charged happening, this annual gathering on the sea edge. Except for Thomas, they all came from elsewhere. Britain, Nigeria, Chile, Finland, America, Canada. To this research station on Australia’s northeast coast, to catch the corals’ rose-hued sexual discharge, separate sperm from egg, play mad scientist.
Clare clattered out of the dorms, sat on the step beneath where Colby was rocking. She was still wearing her white peasant skirt, even though she had spilled salsa all over it. They watched Olatokunbo pick up one of the undergrads and twirl her around, her bare feet raised behind her, scalloped with sand.
“Anna-Maria and I think this is going to be the year,” Clare said, as if picking up a prior conversation. “We’ve mapped out enough couplings between northern and southern species that we should, hopefully, hit gold. Hit pay dirt.” She was tapping her fingers along the wood of the step, each nail a different colour: coral blue, coral pink. Chalk white. “Hopefully,” she repeated.
Everybody here had their reasons, their story: why they fell in love with the ocean, with the wrack. The reef. And that was Clare’s: having made her escape from a suffocating evangelical childhood, she now pursued the need to save these bright, cathedral-esque life forms with intense, nearly religious zeal, to crossbreed and crossbreed and crossbreed again, under various and mounting stresses, until a new species evolved. Anna-Maria was the world-renowned scientist, the project leader, the one who conceptualized augmented evolution to begin with, the one who won the grants. Thomas, founder and head of the Reef Revitalization Nursery and Laboratory, was the disgruntled son of the second-richest coal-mining family in Australia. Through RRNL, Thomas was going to keep the reefs alive, to do what he could to undo the planetary damage his family had wrought. For Olatokunbo, it was the science of it, the symbiotic attraction between coral polyp and algae, the mystery of Darwin’s Paradox—how could such life thrive in the nutrient-starved waters of the tropics? He brought infectious joy to everything he touched, kept undergrads enthused and donors pleased. Then there were the non-scientists, the hangers-on of various stripes. Helmut, who, along with his parents and six brothers, worked at his family’s tabletop game company, Elämää Games; their forest-ecosystem game Boreal! was a massive sleeper hit. He arrived at RRNL three years ago to research for a sequel based on the mind-bogglingly complex ecology of the reef and had been back every November since. Jana was a video journalist—though as she told anybody who would listen, she was actually a failed novelist—making a self-funded documentary on Anna-Maria and her noble attempt to save the coral, sticking herself and her camera into everybody’s business.
And then there was Colby. Why was Colby here? She wasn’t exactly sure. She didn’t even like the coral, not really, not like the others. In fact, it terrified her, had since she first watched Finding Nemo with her sister. But, still, she found herself majoring in biology, doing a master’s in oceanography, and suddenly there was Anna-Maria in her lab offering Colby a cushy three-year contract as her assistant: she’d be based in San Diego, travel the world, the yearly pilgrimage to Australia. So, Colby said yes. And, for some reason she didn’t quite understand, she excelled at it, was, as Anna-Maria never failed to mention, “indispensable”; it was that very word, indispensable, that accompanied a picture of Colby in National Geographic, posing next to a tank of orange coral, a pipette in hand, a confident yet—to Colby, at least—slightly sour smile on her face. The more time she spent with the corals, the more obsessed and repulsed she became, the more unsure she became of this project she was enmeshed in, the more alien the reefs grew—their symbiosis, their unearthly cityscapes, their communal sexual explosions. But, as Helmut said the morning of his arrival, the two of them half on the bed, half on the floor: anything that is not human seems alien. Colby responded that sometimes humans seemed like the most alien species on the planet. Steadily dreaming our anthropic dream.
“I think Jana wants to sleep with me,” Clare announced.
Olatokunbo and the undergrads were walking up the beach, almost at the dorm steps. Clare waved and smiled at her boyfriend, who bent down and scooped her up, whispered something into her ear. Watching Clare and Olatokunbo, Colby thought of Helmut, inside with his vodka bottle, probably getting bored of waiting for her. He had asked if, since her contract was over anyway, she’d come back to Finland with him; she had told him she was going to the kitchen for a beer.
Over the sea, the red blink of a satellite carving through constellations.
They truly were a wonder. The reefs. Home to endless varieties of fish, urchin, clam, shark, octopus, crab, sea star, sponge, oyster, turtle, celled life singular and multiple. The plasticene wonder of it. The colours! Orange, gold, and brown. Fuchsia, pink, and teal. Yellow, blue, and green. The corals themselves built drip by drip, nib by nib, over tens of millions of years. But now, it was a race against rising ocean temperatures, against coral bleaching. Against death. A race to breed a new coral that was more heat-resistant, that didn’t expel their algal counter parts at the first sign of trouble, that could live in an altered world. As Thomas liked to say, if the coral goes, the entire script of the ocean will be rewritten. The entire script, period.
The second night. The air of the sea lab murky with expectation. Thomas’s husband, James, had just arrived from Melbourne, had his headlamp on the regular light setting until Jana whispered in his ear and he fixed it, Jana returning to panning over the tanks that simulate ocean conditions in twenty years, in fifty years, in one hundred. Anna Maria stood by the stainless-steel lab tables in a white lab coat, clipboard in her hands, a mother unhappy her brood were not performing.
Around ten o’clock, one coral let out a pip of gamete. Otherwise, nothing.
“Somebody get these guys some oysters,” Olatokunbo said.
Midnight: a river of red toward the door.
Colby ended the call from Toronto. She was standing at her dorm room window, watching the feral pigs rooting in the dumpsters; her sister had just informed her the cancer had metastasized, was back. Watching the pigs, she thought about how mammals many times larger than humans don’t have higher occurrences of cancer, even though they have thousands of times more cells. Peto’s Paradox. Elephants’ recompense for never inventing the oil derrick? Colby had stayed away from Toronto for three years, but her contract with Anna-Maria was over; there was no reason not to return home.
Downstairs, the dorm kitchen was full of people. Everybody was drinking, telling stories, laughing. The undergrads came in, hysterical, spooked by the pigs. The talk turned to roadside wallabies, the scourge of the cane toad, the fires that, not even three years ago, had killed a neat billion. Colby and Helmut chipped away on their nightly group project of the vodka bottle.
Jana turned her camera on, asked if it’s actually even possible to save the coral. Colby stared at Jana’s earrings, two house keys, one gold, one silver. What doors did they unlock?
“Yes, but augmented evolution is only one piece of the puzzle,” Thomas said, leaning back. “We need to slow the heating of the ocean. Brighten the clouds, block the sun. Pump in cold water, deploy robots to reseed damaged reefs. Anything and everything.”
“As long as it’s scalable,” Anna-Maria interjected.
“Yes, yes, of course. Scalable. The latest euphemism for money.” Clare had told Colby that Thomas’s parents had recently cut him out of their will; if it wasn’t for Anna-Maria and her grants, RNNL would be shuttered. “The only truly scalable technology is human beings. But if we can buy the corals twenty, thirty years, maybe we’ll have come to enough sense.”
Colby watched this exchange through slitted eyes.
“I wish somebody would do some augmented evolution with me,” Clare sighed. She was curled up with Olatokunbo on the futon, but was looking at Jana, who was filming James brag about a fishing trip he had just come back from in Canada’s Northwest Territories, the amphibious vehicle they had rode out into the frothing lake, fish the size of compact cars.
The undergrads turned up the music, started dancing.
Later, Anna-Maria was loudly fighting with Thomas about the Fermi Paradox. Everybody had paused to watch.
“Either interstellar travel is impossible, or there is no other life in the universe,” Anna-Maria stated in her determinative way. “I tend to the latter.”
“Bullshit!” Thomas said, nearly yelling. Colby had never seen him so animated. Clare often said that Thomas had had his blood medically replaced with liquified self-importance; Colby had never seen it, not until now. “The universe is big enough for trillions of advanced civilizations. They just haven’t gotten to us yet. I have to believe that. Otherwise, tell me, please, what’s the point?”
Olatokunbo tried to break up the argument. “Maybe they’re waiting for us to solve our own problems.”
“Don’t hold your breath.”
Don’t hold your breath.
Colby was with Helmut at the kitchen sink, filling their mugs with water. She leaned into him as they let the water run cold. Helmut was a big guy, with a big beard, big eyes, a big brain, big appetites.
“Have you thought about it?” he asked. Colby took a step back.
Finland.
“Seeing you once a year is no longer enough,” he said.
“I don’t know. Maybe.” Colby was stunned at her own words.
Helmut took her by the waist. “I need your expertise with the game. Plus, my brothers are dying to meet you.” The game. The game! For Helmut, it was easy. You did this, you got this in return. You picked a card, you got a reward. Augmented evolution. Put the right egg and sperm together, make something better.
Colby took a drink of the lukewarm water, flavoured with the faintest hint of sulphur. She knew she didn’t want to go with Helmut, but why not? They had fun. The sex was great. She had nowhere else to be, not really. Except for Toronto, her sister. The disease.
“Sometimes, I hate everybody,” she said. “Everybody, and everything.”
“What?” Helmut asked.
“I said, I hope your brothers agree with your new idea for the reef spawning mechanic.”
Helmut’s face was a mask of Finnish fortitude.
Colby scanned the kitchen. The undergrads had found an ancient Twister mat, were contorted into unnatural shapes. Olatokunbo was sitting cross-legged on the floor, staring at the wall. Clare and Jana were no longer present; Thomas had reamed Jana out after discovering that she was planning on using her documentary to get funding from Silicon Valley, and Clare had escorted Jana to her dorm room to comfort her. Olatokunbo jumped up. “The night, she is young! Who wants to go for a swim?” The undergrads collapsed, laughed, jumped up, followed Olatokunbo out the door.
Colby took Helmut’s hand.
Time for bed.
Shortly after lights out, on the third night, it happened.
First, there was a spitting. Then, a sputtering. Finally, a storming, the tanks clouding with red. Cheering and high-fives. The lights went back up. Anna-Maria and Colby rushed around with their clipboards, their lists of the desired pairings. The undergrads helped Olatokunbo and Clare catch the gamete slicks, sieve out the sperm from the eggs, transfer the sperm into buckets, send the buckets to the appointed workstations. The two of them joking and laughing, holding hands. Jana everywhere with her camera; she had removed the key earrings, two little nubs where the holes in her skin were already beginning to fuse. Helmut, for the first time Colby had known him, seemed out of place, his big blonde bulk removed from the action.
They worked into the night. The dorm rooms forgotten.
Colby stood with her feet in the chilled surf, the sky beginning to boil with the dawn. The team had only just finished pairing the coral. Now, we wait. Colby’s role in this experiment was, at least momentarily, complete; until Anna-Maria sorted her latest grant, Colby was a free agent. Her small white duffle was packed and waiting for her by the brown rocking chair. Shortly after Helmut had wandered off to bed, around four thirty, kissing Colby on the forehead and saying he’d see her in the morning, she had slipped out from the frenzy, ran to the dorm and booked a very expensive flight to Toronto. She had hastily packed, had every intention of getting right into her rental car and driving to the airport, but felt compelled to say goodbye to the ocean.
Colby let the sunrise sting her eyes. Tomorrow, nearly everybody else would be leaving, headed back to their wired corners of the globe. She tore her eyes from the new day’s succor, looked up. Pictured airplanes in the sky, their trails of exhaust criss-crossing, expanding, melting into the air.
Aaron kreuter
is the author of six books. His most recent poetry collection, Shifting Baseline Syndrome, was a finalist for the 2022 Governor General’s Award, and was shortlisted for the 2022 Raymond Souster Award and the 2023 Vine Awards for Jewish Literature. Aaron’s first novel, Lake Burntshore, was released in spring 2025. He lives in Toronto and is an assistant professor at Trent University.